"Prudent Cooperators of the Episcopal College" (Lumen Gentium 28)
An Understanding of the Promise of Obedience in the Rite of Ordination to the Presbyterate
From: Loyola Papers Vol. 6 No. 1 (2025)
Abstract
This paper investigates the theological meaning of the presbyter's promise of obedience within the rite of ordination, framed by Lumen Gentium 28's description of priests as "prudent cooperators of the episcopal order." Tracing the historical development of the promise from its implicit expectations in the early Church, through Boniface's personalistic pledge, the Romano-Germanic Pontifical's will-you-I-will formula, the immixtio manuum gesture, and the juridical emphasis of the Tridentine Pontifical, to the 1968 and 1990 postconciliar rites, the author shows how obedience shifted from a feudal-juridical bond into a relational, communal expression rooted in the shared priesthood of bishop and presbyter. The paper concludes that authentic obedience is not blind submission but a reciprocal, trust-based cooperation that safeguards both ecclesial communion and the presbyter's genuine freedom in mission.
